Monday, November 27, 2006

more of a litter than a family

have you seen or heard about the duggar family? they have sixteen children. yes, sixteen. they're pretty much famous for having a giant brood; they even have their own special on tlc about the house they built to fit them all.

i come from a long line of huge families. on my pop's side, until his generation there wasn't a family with less than eight kids. i have a ridiculous amount of cousins. mom's family was pretty big until they moved to the states, so i don't have quite as many cousins on that side of things. i am not anti-big-family, but the duggars make me uneasy.

it's hard to pinpoint exactly what makes me feel weird about them and at the same time compelled to watch their specials on tv, but the first thing that comes to mind when i think of them is that it's more of a litter than a family. mom seems to be just a breeding machine. a strangely perky, placid, brainwashed machine. having kids and being a mom is a totally worthwhile endeavor, but it seems like they've taken it to a seriously crazy extreme. mom is practically a baby-making-factory, and i can't imagine one set of parents being able to give all those kids any serious amount of attention. at the same time i think about how school teachers usually deal with more than sixteen, and they do it all day. of course, eight hours isn't exactly twenty-four.

their roles in the family also seem to be pretty rigidly gender-based. the girls help with cleaning, cooking, and other typically feminine stuff. the boys do garbage, yard work, that sort of thing. it makes me wonder what kind of chaos might break out if one of the many, many girls said, "hey, i'd rather mow the lawn today than babysit my younger brothers or sisters." and how come none of the girls get to wear a pair of pants? i mean, i'm fairly sure pants don't make you a man. the older children also have quite a lot of work to do, there seems to be very little time for them to hang out. when are they going to get to be angsty teenagers? or write bad poetry, discover morrissey and learn about the world outside their house? instead they have to be stand-in moms and dads. there isn't a whole lot of privacy built into the house either, with everyone sleeping in giant rooms all together. i would have been one seriously dark kid if i grew up in that house. oh wait, my parents are reasonable! i didn't have to! with their new compound all built, there isn't much chance of them getting to interact with the outside world, which is probably the point. education in that house must also be a bit of a joke, when on earth is there time to study? they don't even get to leave the house for school. the only meaningful interaction they have is with their own family and other families like them. will the duggar children know what they might be able to be outside of moms or dads? how could they pay for college? will they even be encouraged to attend college? or just grow up, get out of the house, and start their own mega-families?

i just think is this one example of where bigger might not be better. although i do kind of want to try their tater-tot casserole recipe.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well now, aren't they just the epitome of wholesome. Please excuse me whilst I gaggeth.

The tater-tot casserole does redeem them a little, though. A little.

Anonymous said...

i love the shows. they make me super uncomfortable. especially when they all wear the same colors, and their names all start with the same letters, and they pretend to be normal BUT THEY AIN'T.
-chew

Unknown said...

i have seen this, and wondered a lot of the same things... and! it was kinda weird when the boys didn't even get to wear jeans to build the house. unless they did and i missed it.

i think they might be pentecostal... and if i remember correctly from the pentecostal girls i used to work with, its the idea within the religion that women make babies and wear their hair long and their skirts longer. of course they explained it not so bluntly to me.

Anne said...

Not alot of veggies in any of the ol' Duggar recipes.... I've seen that when they go out in public they dress alike so they don't forget/lose anyone. Definitely not the way I'd like to spend my life!

Anonymous said...

I have seen these shows too, and they are re-airing them and I keep watching them. Why?? I don't know.

Girls can't wear pants because it accentuates their bodies and they are more about their spiritual beauty rather than physical. At least, that's pretty much what the mom says in one episode. I'm pretty sure they are Pentecostal, too, which has a lot of strange rules like the hair and skirts...

Some of the girls actually seem pretty normal, except when they said the one thing they were looking forward to in the new house was more space to do laundry! I love doing laundry! I mean, it's cool that you like to help out (and I know they have to)... but shouldn't girls be more excited about other things?

On the one hand I think old-fashioned families are good... and homeschooling can have benefits... but I think they maybe have gone too far with it. Way too far.

Oh yes, the Duggar compound - did you see where they were saying that they bought enough land so that the kids could build their own houses there if they want?

Anonymous said...

It scares the crap out of me just thinking that I could have been born into a family like that!
Tabitha99